Skip to main content
601-656-5568

Payroll

What should employers check before preparing 2026 W-2s?

Before year-end payroll closes, check employee details, missing payments, benefits and reporting responsibilities so W-2 preparation starts with complete records.

By McNeel CPAPublished 4 min read

If you own a small business, it is easy to assume that year-end payroll is handled once every employee has been paid. But the person preparing your W-2s needs more than the last payroll run. They need a complete record of the year and a clear explanation of anything unusual. This federal payroll checklist helps you organize that conversation for 2026 without waiting until forms are ready to send.

The practical takeaway

Ask for a year-to-date payroll review now. Resolve missing information, identify payments outside normal payroll and agree on who will review, file and deliver the final forms.

1. Start with the employee list

Review everyone paid during the year, including employees who left. Confirm current mailing addresses and check for duplicate employee profiles. A former employee can be easy to overlook when the payroll dashboard defaults to active staff.

The IRS instructs employers to use the employee's name and Social Security number as shown on their Social Security card. Handle a name change through the appropriate verification process instead of simply replacing the payroll name with a nickname or a newly supplied surname.

Have employees review their information through your established secure process. Keep sensitive identifiers out of group messages. Make a short tracking list showing which records need attention, who will resolve them and when you expect the correction.

2. Gather the payroll activity the system might be missing

Pull the year-to-date payroll register, filed payroll tax returns and payment confirmations. Collect records from every provider used during 2026. If you changed systems, ask which provider will prepare the year-end forms and how earlier payroll was brought forward.

Review manual checks, replacement checks, bonuses and payments made outside the usual payroll process. For each item, document whether it already appears in payroll. The goal is to find omissions without entering the same payment twice.

The IRS calls for reconciling W-2 and W-3 totals with the applicable employment tax returns. Differences can have valid explanations; investigate and document them rather than forcing the figures to match. Ask your preparer to distinguish wage amounts, employee withholding and employer taxes during this review.

  • Label every report with its period and the date it was downloaded.
  • Keep a separate list of unresolved items instead of altering reports to hide differences.
  • Identify any payroll tax notices or corrections already in progress.

3. Review benefits and the 2026 reporting changes

Create a list of benefits and employee gifts provided outside ordinary wages. Include what was provided, who received it and the supporting records. Ask the payroll preparer which items require a valuation, a payroll adjustment or separate reporting.

IRS Publication 15-B explains that cash and cash-equivalent gifts, such as gift cards, do not qualify for the small-benefit exclusion merely because their value is low. Benefit rules have specific exclusions and conditions, so do not apply one treatment to every gift or reimbursement.

The 2026 W-2 instructions add reporting for cash tips and qualified overtime, including new box 12 codes and tipped occupation information. If these apply, ask whether your records and software capture the required information. Do not assume every payment labeled overtime is qualified overtime.

Raise these questions while the underlying time, payment and benefit records are still easy to retrieve. This checklist is a preparation aid; your preparer should apply the current instructions to the particular benefits and compensation involved.

4. Agree on who does what

Write down who will approve the final payroll figures, submit the forms, deliver employee copies and respond if a filing is rejected. Ask for the provider's internal cutoff date and a plan for handling corrections. Confirm the applicable federal deadlines and any relevant relief separately from that internal schedule.

Using a routine payroll service does not generally remove the employer's federal tax responsibilities. The IRS recommends monitoring deposits made on your behalf. Ask how you can obtain filing acknowledgments and verify tax payments, and keep those records with your payroll files.

5. Bring a focused question to your consultation

A useful opening is: “Here are our 2026 payroll reports, the providers we used and the items we have not resolved. What needs attention before we finalize W-2s?” Bring a concise list of gaps along with the records, rather than waiting until every issue is solved.

This article covers federal payroll preparation. State and local reporting must be reviewed separately, including where employees worked. McNeel CPA can discuss business-service needs and confirm the scope and availability of payroll or state-specific assistance. Use the consultation link for general contact details; arrange an approved secure method before sharing employee records.

Sources & further reading

Sources checked November 8, 2026.

This article provides general education, not advice for a particular taxpayer. Tax rules and individual circumstances can change. Contact our office to discuss your facts and the scope of assistance available. A consultation request does not establish representation or extend any deadline.

Turn your questions into a plan.

Talk with McNeel CPA about tax preparation, bookkeeping, payroll or federal IRS help. Use the inquiry form for general details; our office will provide instructions for sharing sensitive documents.

Request a free consultationCall 601-656-5568
Call UsSchedule